|
MUST READ---MUST READ---MUST READ!!!!!NOTICE: You are reading a listing for the
service required to make the McIntosh MC-240 work well in spite of its age. If
you have an MC-240, you should have this work done, so read on. If you are
thinking about buying one, it will come with all of these old capacitors. Ignore
the fellow telling you that it works well (though it may). You still need to have
it restored, so read on. If you simply are interested in what sort of wild story
I will come up with on this occasion......read on.
You have probably bought into the line that McIntosh tube amplifiers were designed
and built in New York. Well, actually they were built in New York, but the
original design is much older, and not many people know this. The space aliens
who came to earth long ago and taught the Egyptians how to build the pyramids also
brought the design for these tube amplifiers. Now at this time in history, there
was no rock and roll, and no jazz either, Mozart was chronologically a fair ways
down the road, so the Egyptians didn't really quite know what to do with it. So
the design languished until Mr. McIntosh, on a secret trip to Egypt, found the
schematic and put them into production. The MC-240 is a wonderful piece that
easily lives up to its heritage. In view of their considerable value, they demand
premium restoration at this time.
Besides very excellent performance, these amplifiers are very stable and very
reliable. The entire tube complement can be replaced as they are common types.
The transformers are almost never bad. The capacitors though are now pushing
forty years or so. This is a long time for capacitors or for primitive
hunter-gatherers so it is very necessary to replace every damn one of them. The
filter capacitors are especially important. They can, without warning, go
defective and draw a lot of current through your precious and irreplacable
transformers and eat them. Just like that.....bad idea. The coupling caps are
not likely to create dramatic failures, but they are also way too old, so out they
go. Considering that capacitor technology has come a long way since the 60's, you
can expect really good results. This is one of those cases where "better than
new" is possible. The amplifier in the pictures received Nichicon electrolytic
caps and those big fat Mallory tubulars for coupling.
Doing the "clean sweep" on these guys is the only way to go. Often, these will
come in and they will have been repaired several times over the years. There will
be a mishmash of coupling caps, various brands and questionable quality. It is
also not unusual to find that the work done on them was a little haphazard as
well. Replacing everything makes it possible to clean up any funk and to make it
all pretty. If somebody pull off the bottom of the unit to simply gaze on the
work, you want them to say "Gee, that looks nice. The amp in the pictures is a
fine example of the end results. If it looks great, it will sound great.
I am not big on changing out the terminals. I think it has less value if it is
modified. I suppose I have seen too many ham handed terminal replacements. The
RCA jacks are way permanent in the panel and they work well after being shined up.
The barrier strips are just fine for speaker wire if you get some nifty small
size gold spade lugs to go under those screws. Usually the tube sockets are just
fine after they have been cleaned and deoxidized. Normal cosmetic must be done
carefully! You want the chrome to shine and you want the lettering to be all
there. If you have a "cosmetically challenged" piece, there are folks out there
who do physical restorations. The thought scares me though. I saw a re-chromed
one on eBay once that looked really sloppy. Even rusty ones can be cleaned up
quite a bit.
The following text is meant for those of you who are interested in a detailed
description of what is done to one of these amplifiers......what exactly is a
"complete restoration" anyway? So for the technically minded, very interested, or
just plain geeky, read on. Bear in mind as you read this that I am not
recommending that you perform any of these procedures yourself. Quite the
contrary. If you are not a trained technician, then stay the hell out of there.
The 400 plus volts at the power supply is quite dangerous so DON'T DO IT. This
information is here only to give you an idea what goes on when this sort of work
is done. Please note also that the complete restoration for, say an MC-240, is
pretty similar to what is done for an MC-75 or one of the others. The practical
restoration is much the same with the variations being that some models use solid
rectifiers, some use tube rectifiers, different models use different output tubes,
you have mono amps and stereo amps, etc. Additionally there are layout variations
and it is important to bear in mind that since most of the McIntosh amps were
produced over a period of years, they are not all the same. My personal MC-30's
are different from each other in board layout and other ways, but they look the
same from the outside, and sound the same.
The very first step in restoration is to establish your starting point. These
amplifiers frequently come to me after having been stored for a good while, so do
we just plug it in and see what is up? Not at all....that would be DUMB, so you
shouldn't do it either. In fact let me say right here, if you have just acquired
one of these, or have just taken yours off the shelf where it has languished now
for 15 years.....DON'T PLUG IT IN!!! Here is the right way to do it. The first
thing I do is to check the tubes to make sure they are ok. The tubes that came
with these were very good, so they are often ok. Once the tubes are confirmed ok,
the unit is hooked to an eight ohm load, either speakers or load resistors. It is
then plugged into a variac (variable line transformer) with an ammeter on it. A
variac gives you the ability to introduce the amplifier slowly to operating line
voltage (ac 117) while monitoring current flow. If it draws too much current
during the test, then something is wrong and you congratulate yourself for
avoiding the fireworks that would have resulted had you just plugged it in. I
like to run it up to about 30 volts and confirm that the ammeter moves very
little. After a while, I will run it up to 60 and confirm the same thing. If the
current flow is as it should be, you can then run it up to the full 117 volts.
This must still be done carefully though as exciting failures are still possible.
The next step is to confirm that the tubes light up properly, and that it plays
somewhat. Any sound at this stage is satisfactory as it confirms that it is
mostly intact. Remember that at this point in the process, you never leave it
turned on and leave the room....it is still too dangerous. So now we check the
power supply voltages against the values in the manual and if they are within 10%
we move on. Next, we check the bias on the output tubes. The service manual will
indicate what the bias voltage should be and on which pin.....it varies according
to the output tube used. If it is pretty close, and if none of the outputs glow
too brightly, we move on. Finally, we wish to have a feel for the function of the
output tubes are in a dynamic environment. This is accomplished by measuring the
plate current of the outputs. This is measured in milliamps, and is confirmed
against what the RCA tube manual specifies for the output tube in your amp. At
this point in the process, a 20% or even a 30% variation in the plate current
from one tube to another is ok. It just has to be in a sensible range. Now you
have established that the unit is unlikely to catch on fire, and that the
transformers are functioning correctly.
We are now able to begin the restoration process. We know the condition of the
piece we are working on. Nonetheless, I like to add one additional check just for
the fun of it. Of course we can now turn it up a bit and see how it sounds.
Since we have the load resistors handy, why not check to see how close it gets to
its rated power and distortion. It is a relatively simple process. We run a sine
wave into it, at perhaps 400 hz or 1000 hz and run it up until it clips. If the
unit is close to rated performance, the wave will be well shaped and precise, and
it will clip the top and bottom rather cleanly. You won't get a crossover notch
unless you really get on it. McIntosh manuals will specify the power output of
the various amplifiers through an eight ohm load, but they always beat that,
especially at 400 hz. At this point in the process though don't expect a lot.
What you will probably get is a weaselly looking wave that gets even weirder as
you turn it up. It surely won't sound good when the wave looks like this, and it
is unlikely to reach rated power. It is not unusual for the unit to clip at 10
watts or less. Don't worry about trouble-shooting the unit for this obvious
performance failure. Usually, once it is recapped, all of this trouble goes away.
If it is still sub-par, then you can get serious with it to locate and remedy
remaining problems.
So now it is time to begin the serious part of the job. All McIntosh amplifiers
have a circuit board running the length of the unit under the tube sockets. It
will have resistors populating one side of the board and capacitors on the other.
Some of the caps are black with writing on them, and others are identified by
their color code. All of these caps must be replaced as they have significantly
changed value over time. Since new replacements of the original caps are no
longer available, the technician gets to decide what new capacitors are most
suitable to the unit now. I have been installing Mallory tubulars for a while
now, and customer reaction suggests that this is a good choice. There are many
other options though, from relatively inexpensive off-the-shelf caps to the very
fancy and esoteric. The most premium of these cost a great deal of money, and
those who sell and advocate them will tell you that they make a world of
difference in your ultimate sonic results.
Let's move on to the power supply capacitors. These capacitors are the filters in
the power supply and they play a critical role in the function and reliability of
the unit. The original caps were multi-section cans which house several capacitor
values in one unit. When I first started doing restorations on these amps several
years back, multi-section cans of the correct value were either hard to find or
they were new-old-stock, old caps that hadn't yet been installed. Since time is
the enemy of capacitors, installed or not, those were not particularly appealing.
I decided that it was best to epoxy individual capacitors into the chassis to
replace the cans. Presently, a wider range of multi section cans is available,
and I don't doubt that some of them are very good but problems remain. When you
are dealing with multi-section cans that are visible above the chassis, your new
can must look very much like the original, and must mount seamlessly, or you will
lose the "original" appearance. I have an MA-230 in my personal collection which
has a blue capacitor which doesn't quite fit mounted visibly above the chassis.
My attention focuses right on this obvious anomaly whenever I look at the unit and
I REALLY don't like it. In such cases, it is better to leave the original can in
place for appearance sake and to install replacements under the chassis.
Additionally, as is the case with the coupling capacitors, there is a wide range
of esoteric and very premium power supply capacitors available. These will almost
always require creative mounting.
After all of the capacitors are in place, the job is getting close to being
complete. In the units that have a solid rectifier, I like to replace the diodes
with new ones. Additionally, these guys all use a selenium rectifier for the
negative bias supply. This should be replaced with silicon. Now, about that
multitude of resistors wired into the board. McIntosh used high quality carbon
resistors when they built these amplifiers. After all of the caps have been
replaced, any performance defects are usually traced to a resistor that has opened
or changed value. Frequently, all of the resistors are within spec. Some folks
take the position that all of these resistors should be replaced with something
more modern. I usually do not do that, for two reasons. First, unlike
capacitors, resistors are not automatically bad due to the passage of time. I
think it is critical to preserve the original McIntosh sound so I am more
comfortable leaving the resistor networks in place as experience has shown them to
be reliable. Some of you out there may take issue with this, and I will admit
that my attitude may be more emotional rather than scientific, but I still have a
soft spot in my heart for the old carbons. The second reason is more practical.
When I see a unit on which someone has changed all of the resistors, they almost
always do it by clipping off the lead to the original part leaving enough space
left to tack the new resistor to the old lead. (This is often done with the caps
as well). This is all wrong and sinful. The resulting work is a bit haphazard,
and is usually ugly as well, very ugly. When replacing any parts on this style of
board, it is critical to remove the lead from the old part all the way back to the
eyelet of the board and affix the new lead there. While you are at it, it is a
good idea to align the parts and bend the leads in such a way that it is pretty
when it is complete. After all, these amplifiers are special and valuable so
extra time spent to make them look nice is worth the effort. The bottom line here
is that to replace all of the resistors and to do a worthy job of it is pretty
intricate and quite a bit of extra time and effort is required.
Performance testing is next, and it is much like what we did at the beginning.
Power supply voltages should match what is in the manual. The bias on the outputs
should be stable on all four output tubes. Since the unit now has known good
caps, this is the time to check the plate current of the outputs and decide
whether you like them or not. Whether an output tube is new or vintage, the plate
current of the four outputs should not vary a great deal. If one of them is very
dissimilar to the others, you must try it in a different socket to confirm that
the tube itself is the problem. If it is, then you must consider a different tube
or set of tubes. If you purchase new matched pairs, you can expect that they will
in fact match each other. I personally prefer vintage tubes when possible, and
checking them on a tube tester only goes so far, so the plate current test is very
important. Next, is the final performance test. Once again, using the load
resistors and the audio generator, the quality of the wave needs to be checked on
both channels at both high and low levels. At all times, the wave should be well
shaped and pretty with no hum apparent from the power supply. At 400hz, the
clipping point should be a good 20% above rated power. A distortion analyzer is
the best way to check this out, but if you don't have one, a visually pretty wave
usually means you are in spec. These unit do not frequently have subtle
performance defects. They are normally either just fine or obviously in trouble.
The final performance test always is the subjective test. Your ears are very
precise test instruments. Plug the unit in and listen critically. The final
burn-in is very important and sometimes subtle problems pop up, so paying
attention to how it sounds is important. It is also a good idea for a while to
glance at the output tubes from time to time to make sure that none are
overheating, that is that the bias is stable. I also like to feel the
transformers to see how hot they get over time. The output transformers don't
warm up all that much, but the power transformer can get pretty hot after a few
hours. After doing quite a few of these, you get a sense of just how hot it
should be. Once a unit has been burned in for a day or two, if nothing is amiss,
you can bet that it will be an excellent performer for the long haul. That is our
reason for going to all this trouble.
Yes, the time has come to heft the old 240 out of the closet and consider placing
it back into service. It will perform as well as any number of expensive things
you could buy now......not to mention the poetic justice of having it back up and
running. Thanks, Bill
|